Interpreting Prophetic Writings – Discussion Starters

Sabbath School Teaching Tip: One way to engage more quiet members is to do a quick “lightning round” wherein you ask a question and go around the circle asking each member to answer. A member can pass in the moment and then you come back to them. This works best with a relatively simple, short answer type of question, e.g., “Name a Scripture verse or Ellen White quote that you think is at risk of misinterpretation.” Or, even simpler, a quick multiple choice question to warm up the group, e.g., “Do you have a most treasured copy of the Bible in your family (or, a favorite translation of the Bible) and why?”
- Our author proposes (see Wednesday) an expanding set of concentric circles approach to Biblical interpretation. First, understand the words. Then, understand their context (what comes before and after in the passage). Third, understand the historical-cultural setting (who was writing, at what time, to what people, for what purpose). Finally, situate any understanding within the whole overarching message of Scripture.
Are you familiar with this method of interpretation?
If not, how where you taught to interpret Scripture?
If so, how has this method been helpful to your understanding of Scripture? Can you share an example of the benefits of this concentric circle approach?
2. Prior to the American Civil War, slaveholders quoted “Slaves, obey your earthly masters with respect and fear, and with sincerity of heart, just as you would obey Christ” (Eph 6:5) to justify slavery. Using the concentric circles method above, explain what is flawed in their interpretation.
3. David Powlison was a legendary Christian counselor who pointed out that the counsel we give often has to be temporarily unbalanced, and then later rebalanced by the whole of Scripture as the person’s situation changes. For example, one counselee needs to hear of the overwhelming mercy of God, while another needs to hear a prophetic warning about the judgment of sin. Giving the verse each needs in the moment is helpful. But, in total isolation from the rest of the gospel, either of those messages would be so unbalanced as to distort the gospel. How could the same be true of the “counsels” we take from Scripture or Ellen White? Can you think of examples where these counsels could be temporarily “unbalanced” in a helpful way for a particular person in a particular situation, but problematically unbalanced if isolated from the whole of the gospel?
4. Scripture interprets itself. Yet, people sometimes sincerely disagree on its interpretation. Do you give any people or communities more weight than others in such disagreements? If so, on what basis? For exampe, their current office? Their education? Their character? Their historical reputation in the church?
5. If you were struggling with understanding a passage of Scripture, do you think God would rather have you defer to a particular authority’s interpretation, or stand on your own interpretation? Why?
6.How has being embedded in a healthy Christian community expanded and enlightened your understanding of the whole gospel? How can staying embedded in a healthy Christian community help prevent distorted interpretations of Scripture or prophetic writings? How can you judge whether your Christian community is healthy?
7. Do you think it is fair to judge a particular interpretation of Scripture or prophecy based on the fruits and consequences that seem to consistently flow from that particular interpretation? Why or why not?
8. In the early Church, the nature of Christ (fully human and fully Divine) was a hotly debated interpretive issue. At the time of the Reformation, the role of faith and works in salvation was a hotly debated interpretive issue. What do you see as hotly debated interpretive issues today?
