HomeDailyTuesday: Learning From the Past    

Comments

Tuesday: Learning From the Past — 15 Comments

  1. There are a couple of problems about “learning from the past”.

    • Most of us don’t like reading history. I once organised a workshop on using computers in education. A student doing a major in history started his session by saying that the main purpose of studying history was to teach us how to handle boredom. I think he captured the essence of how most of us feel about history.
    • If we do take the plunge and study history, we often get selective. We read the bits that reinforce what we believe and ignore the rest.
    • Perhaps then, it is not surprising that the only lesson we learn from history is that we do not learn from history.

    I am an anomoly in some respects. Despite my science/technology career, I read history as a bit of light reading. I find it fascinating to read about the personalities of the past and how they thought about issues. I have mentioned my interest in Adventist Church history from time to time in this forum. A lot of our history has been written with rose-tinted glasses on and it has taken time for some more careful historians to look beyond “The Lord has led us!” to document some of the mistakes we made and their consequences.

    Is there something I wish we had learned from our history? More than anything else, I wish we had learned to treat one another better, especially when we disagree. In our effort to define truth we have often forgotten the grace of Jesus that we should extend to others, including our own.

    By this shall all men know … If we do not know how to finish that sentence by our actions, maybe we need to read our unvarnished history and learn.

  2. We live in an era when the boundaries of good taste and public decency are constantly being pushed, and in many places they seem to have disappeared altogether. God’s commandments are increasingly dismissed in a culture that rejects the very idea of absolute truth and moral accountability. Those who choose to trust and obey God are often misunderstood, ridiculed, or mocked for warning others about the consequences of sinful choices. Yet 1 Corinthians 10:1–5 reminds believers that God’s dealings with Israel were recorded as a solemn lesson for every generation. Although the Israelites experienced God’s miraculous guidance through the cloud and the sea, received spiritual food and drink, and witnessed His mighty power, “God was not pleased with most of them, for they were struck down in the wilderness” (1 Corinthians 10:5). Their privileges did not guarantee God’s approval because their hearts wandered from Him.

    Paul urges believers to listen carefully to the unmistakable voice of God by learning from the past rather than repeating its failures. We each face the choice either to ignore these divine warnings and suffer avoidable consequences or to follow the faithful examples of those who walked in obedience. Scripture repeatedly calls us to remember and learn: “Now these things occurred as examples to keep us from setting our hearts on evil things as they did” (1 Corinthians 10:6). Likewise, Romans 15:4 teaches, “For everything that was written in the past was written to teach us, so that through the endurance taught in the Scriptures and the encouragement they provide we might have hope.” As Hebrews 3:12 warns, “See to it, brothers and sisters, that none of you has a sinful, unbelieving heart that turns away from the living God.” The wise believer humbly learns from God’s Word and from the experiences of those who have gone before, choosing obedience over regret.

  3. The simple reason that we still easily fall into sin even though God has made a way of escape, is that we don’t stop and think to choose the fire escape that is provided. We would rather walk through the “fire” and think that we won’t get burned. There’s a saying coined by Paul Bragg; “flesh is dumb!”. Indeed it is dumb. We need to be smarter than our dumb flesh. Our carnal nature cries out for fulfillment like a spoiled child. It will throw a tantrum if it doesn’t get it’s way.

    The only way out of this crazy cycle is total death to self, denying what our dumb flesh wants, and living in the spirit, wanting what the spirit wants. The nature that we feed is the nature that will lead. We can’t expect to be victorious if we are feeding our mind the rubbish of the world. GIGO (garbage in, garbage out) is as pertinent to humans as computers.

    • Holy Ghost save us from our sins continue to lead us in paths of righteous moment by moment. Help us to see clearly that in we continue to practice Sim we will miss out of the eternal future Jesus Christ has died for so we can have all the eternal riches and not focus on the temporal short life of self gratification. Open our eyes clearly that we might see that sin separates us from you Heavenly Father and may we hate sin with every vestige of our being. Amen

    • I think we tend to become so comfortable that we believe we can overcome sin on our own. We tap into Christ for deliverance when those sins embarrass us, or threaten to publicly embarrassing us. I agree with you that we need to die to self daily. Understanding that we are nothing without Christ and we need Him. I think we are just too comfortable in our folly. We need to understand the seriousness and the impact of our sins and how we can be lost, if we try to do it on our own.

  4. The Bible consistently portrays human beings as poor learners from their past mistakes/sins. Experience alone normally does not bring about a change of the heart. Information about the past does not bring a lasting transformation. Memory is a poor catalyst for the change of the human heart. The Bible records the cyclical nature of human behaviour rather than transformational. God blesses or rescues people, but sooner or later, people become complacent and become rebellious.

    One might expect the wilderness experience to bring lasting faith and obedience among the Israelites, but instead they repeatedly complained, doubted, and turned to idol worship. Miracles by themselves have no power to change anyone. They only testify to the power of God. Even the “good” people in the Bible did not consistently learn from their past. Noah became drunk after the miraculous flood experience. Abraham lied twice about his wife, Sarah. Jacob deceived, and he was deceived himself. David committed adultery with Bathsheba and arranged for her husband to be killed. Solomon, the wisest human being, later allowed himself to be led into idolatry. One important lesson is coming through: human memory is fragile, unreliable, and easily overwhelmed by the circumstances of life.

    In essence, the problem is not in the information about the past but lies within the human heart. It is well described by the prophet Jeremiah in Jeremiah 17:9, “The human heart is the most deceitful of all things, and desperately wicked. Who really knows how bad it is?”. This is the very reason why the prophet Ezekiel prescribes a new heart of flesh to replace the stony one and a new spirit (Ezekiel 36:26). The Corinthians simply could not be changed by the rich information about the past. They needed a new heart and a new spirit to be able to live the present life victoriously. Likewise, our past, however beautiful it might be, cannot give us the victory we need in the present. That is why Jesus was more concerned about the present rather than the past.

    “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me.” (Luke 9:23)

  5. We prefer to satisfy our selfish and sinful nature than to respect the will of God,though we are followers of Christ . While asking God for strength, we need to be intentional about choosing to obey God.

  6. I appreciate all the insights shared in this blog. I was learning through reading your respective posts. Indeed, regardless of having lessons learned in the past or had read/known the experiences of the people in the past and the lessons that comes with them (like the Israelites), we still sin and constantly fail. That is why we need a daily renewing of our hearts before GOD (Psalm 51:10 & Romans 12:2).

    I just pray and may all of us continually pray for the constant guidance of the Holy Spirit in our lives that we may die daily of our self and be able to withstand in every temptation by GOD’s grace.🙏🙏🙏
    Blessings to all of you😇🙏

  7. “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,” was coined by the Spanish philosopher George Santayana in 1905. It is as relevant today as when first spoken and can be applied to every aspect of our lives. It helps us avoid touching a hot stove a second time, when we are young. You only have to smack your hand with a hammer once to know that it hurts. Why would you do it again? Are we gluttons for punishment?

    Spiritual amnesia keeps us stuck in the same crazy cycle as ancient Israel. We forget God’s goodness and start to question it. Then we set out to do things on our own. That’s where things start to get scary. A definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again while expecting a different outcome.

    “We have nothing to fear for the future, except as we shall forget the way the Lord has led us, and His teaching in our past history.”
    Life Sketches of Ellen G. White (pages 195–196)

  8. The thing, strangely enough, that strikes me most forcefully is the personality of the God that we serve. I would encourage you to read 1 Corinthians 10:1-13 in the NIV.
    The gentle Jesus, “meek and mild” , does not easily fit the picture provided in those Scripture verses. Yet we are dealing with the same God.
    At this point in time my analysis of this Being we call God is that He has high expectations of His children. He is by no stretch of the imagination an indulgent Father. One manner in which His love is demonstrated is that He seriously expects the best from His children and is highly displeased when they fall short of the ideal.
    It would appear that the description of a loving God being simply gentle and mild is dangerously deceptive and should be balanced by the picture of a Being who seriously and passionately expects the very best from His children for whom He has given the very BEST, even our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ.

    • There does seem to be a contrast there. And yet, when I consider the years in the Wilderness, God really was patient. In the situations where His judgment really came down, the people were actively rebelling. They were shaking their fists at God. What more could He do but pour out judgment?

  9. The lesson writer asks: “Why, then, do we still find it so easy to fall into sin? Is it not because we have not asked the Holy Spirit to fill us with His Light which expels the darkness of the old nature?

    Can one really learn from the ‘physically based past’? I don’t think so. What would have enough intrinsic value to keep for the present? And for what purpose? Everything decays and something else take its place. Salomon’s quote is well known: “There is nothing new under the sun,” and I tend to agree with Him. Ecc.1:9. But Jesus stands as the exeption – something new from the old.

    If anything at all, what can mankind learn from the past? That the 10 Commandments, when observed, really lead to being blessed by God and live peaceably with one’s neighbor? As a Christian, I consider the only lasting, empirical learning to be spiritually based and revealed by the Holy Spirit. Everything else is only evidence of the ever-turning wheel of time.

    When looking back to the Beginning of Time, all our Creator cared about was, and still is, for us to learn from Him and so be known by Himhow to be His spiritual children! Have we made any progress? I would say yes, somewhat; especially by better understanding that our Salvation is by our God’s Grace through living our life within His Son Jesus Christ by Faith.

    Yes, we can learn from the past, but only as it pertains to matters of the Spirit. He establishes His work within us one building block at a time, and each one of us follows a very personal path toward Salvation. The more He strips from us the old to replace it with the new nature, the more we go back to the Beginning – timeless Oneness.

  10. It might all depend on what we feed our bodies and minds. If we feed on spiritual things, we have far greater chances of overcoming evil. Filling the mind with thanksgiving does ot allow too much space for complaining.

Leave a Reply

Please read our Comment Guide Lines and note that we have a full-name policy. Please do not submit AI-generated comments!

Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail. (You may subscribe without commenting.)

Please make sure you have provided a full name in the "Name" field and a working email address we can use to contact you, if necessary. (Your email address will not be published.)

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

At a camp meeting 40 years later, I happened to see Dr. I. demonstrating some kind of health product, if I remember correctly. (In my mind, I see only the image of him, much older, but still looking much like he did when I was a student, with a friend by my side.) I lingered a little but did not introduce myself. I briefly wondered whether he recognized me. I’m fairly sure that I was as recognizable to him as he was to me.

Had he changed? Or did he still feel superior in his “humility”? Should I talk to him? I didn’t know how to approach him, and was busy with friends. I still don’t know whether I should have said something. (Maybe I’m just a coward.)

If God wants him to see my story, his and my identity are clear enough in this post, that God can direct him to it.